Muzings From The Edge: That Great Sucking Sound
Like many of you the Lazer has been sitting around mourning what is surely the crippling, if not the death, of our beloved Gulf of Mexico with its crystal clear water and beautiful sugar white sandy beaches. I, an ardent lover of seafood, will feel lost when those beautiful shrimp are not available for grilling when the notion strikes me. And to be quite honest the entire mess really pisses me off. But the more I think about it the more confused I am at who pisses me off more. I mean, let us take a somewhat logical look at this whole process and the blame game without taking any sides.
OK, the easy bad guy here of course is British Petroleum, aka BP and its various subcontractors. It was their well, their rig, their oil, thus, logically, their fault. A simple minded man, like gubernatorial candidate Tim James of Alabama, might say, “makes sense to me, does it to you?” Well, if it does you just have thought the situation through yet. The next best candidate in this mess is a governmental regulatory agency called Mineral Management Service which I have recently learned is supposed to ride herd on the oil industry. Until now I would have guessed that MMS would have had something to do with Mickey Mouse.
Listening to lot of the media chatter these days I might still be right seeing as how there was a lot of fooling around with Minnie Mouse going on. At least those were the charges, and the director of this agency that I had never heard of before either jumped or was pushed, not literally of course, off the ledge of the agency’s top floor. So we obviously got the culprit, right?
Not so fast there quick draw, there may be other players in this dooms day drama. This particular boondoggle reminds me of the Bill Buckner error in the 1986 world series between the Boston Red Sox and the New York Mets. Never mind the fact that going into the tenth inning the Red Sox were ahead by two runs and the relief pitchers could not get an out. Never mind the fact that even after that game was lost the Red Sox had another game to win the series. All anyone really remembers is the ground ball that went between Buckner’s legs in game 6 that allowed the game winning run to score. It was if no one else on the team even played that entire series, or if they did, they play perfectly. Now I know that the consequences of the current Gulf crisis are not even on the same planet as a world series, but the analogy still works. This BP well has been working well for about eight years apparently with no major problems. Consider that there are more than 2200 other oil wells in the Gulf of Mexico in Federal waters cranking out 32% of the United States off shore production of oil. As disastrous as this is it is the first major accident of its kind which is why they are having problems stopping it. I know folks, this is not a popular discussion and there are a lot of people hurting who do not want to hear it, but reality is reality. Now, back to the blame game.
So far we have dis’d on BP and MMS but let us go a bit further shall we. Why was BP out there in the first place and why do we need this agency? BP is out there to make money you might say, and I would respond, “give that man, woman, or child a cigar.” And how do they make money? They sell oil to those want it, not need it, but want it. People tend to forget that this country is like a casino to a gambling addict when it comes to oil. It does not matter how much we get we will use it. In fact this applies to any energy resource we have available, there is no cost too great in order for us continue consuming every particle of natural resource we can get. Where energy is concerned there is giant, extremely loud sucking sound that emanates from America. With this demand we must have suppliers, and with suppliers which, granted are in a risky business, we have government regulators. I think everyone but the lamest Tea-Baggers in the country recognize the need for some oversight of these industries.
Is there going to be corruption between the regulators and the industries, gee, ya think? Congressmen and Senators are receiving millions every year in legal campaign contributions and some in illegal transactions and we think that civil servants will not take a dip at the trough of the good life. If you think otherwise you need reality therapy. So now we have people everywhere screaming, blaming, pointing fingers, holding hearings, and probably stomping their feet wanting to hang somebody, anybody, just a body to make them feel better. There is the old saying, “When you point your finger at someone there are four pointing back at you.”
It is now time to take a brief moment to discuss the problem of dealing with the problem. Trust me here, I do not intend to suggest a remedy. Unlike many pundits I do believe the line by Clint Eastwood, “Every man should know his limitations.” I am not real good a stopping a leak in a garden hose, well actually, I am. Throw the damn thing away and go get a new one. Anyway, there are people in this world who are closer to being experts at handling the oil leak problem than I and from what I hear most of them are already on the job. It seems that since this is a first of it’s kind and all of the solutions are theoretical in nature and may or may not work. I have been watching folks on the Louisiana coast shouting out in desperation for a solution. I can only imagine their pain as they watch their livelihood slowly slipping away and the futility of not being able to do anything. It is akin only to trying to empathize with the families of the West Virginia miners who were waiting in desperation to learn of the fate of their husbands, fathers, or brothers. I guess I can even understand James Carville being so angry with President Obama for not showing up on the coast and, as he put it, “showing some leadership.” I do not remember oil well engineering being on Obama’s resume’ when he was running for president but hey, I could be wrong. And there was also this little problem going on between North and South Korea. But, I am sure that if I were in their shoes I too would be as bad or perhaps even worse about demanding that my problem be handled first and foremost.
Folks, this problem is one that falls squarely on the back of practically everyone in this country in one way or another. We are the blame for the problem whether we want to admit it or not. Until we as a people, and as a nation, truly step up and commit ourselves and resources to getting free of carbon based fuels we will continue to have such disasters. There will be more miners die, more oil well leaks, more oil tanker spills, just more of all of this. While I am not a die hard , card carrying, ultra liberal, tree hugging, bicycle riding naturalist I can look at the logical side of things. So just think; the next time you crank you car to go on vacation; fishermen, the motor you use to go out for your catch; when you turn the thermostat down this summer; of the great sucking sound…
Related articles by Zemanta
- Just Fix It!!! – The Politics of Impotent Rage (themoderatevoice.com)
- BP Reverts to Containing Oil Spill After Plugging Effort Fails (businessweek.com)
- Oil spill damage spreads through Gulf economies (money.cnn.com)
- Our Fix-It Faith and the Oil Spill (nytimes.com)
I have to take a little issue with a few things here. As you may remember we had two oilmen in the white house for 8 years. Our energy policy was done behind closed doors by Cheney with no input by Congress or the public. If you bothered to read the Recovery Act you’d know that it has billions for renewable energy. This was a bill that republicans voted against. The issue falls on the fact that republicans and a few democrats paid for by the oil companies have made the rules to the benefit of oil companies. Not to mention the incompetents that Bush installed.
I personally had been looking into buying an electric car and solar panels when the economy took a dive. Wall Street got a bail out but I sure didn’t.
We can demand change but nothing’s going to change until campaign finance laws change.
Good point Demeur. What’s so frustrating is we need to change campaign finance laws but campaign finance prevents that type of change from being enacted.
I don’t know what the answer is, or if their is an answer that’s doable. Maybe just grassroots efforts man. I have to fight the feeling that lobbyists are too entrenched and it’s hopeless.
Thanks for your input Demeur. You are correct about the prior administration. Actually you are right about all of the prior administrations and to a large degree this one too. I applaud your decision to move to an electric powered vehicle but at this point in time we are still producing most electricity with carbon based fuels. We in America have been going through this for four or five decades now with a lot of mouthy talk by presidents and congresspeople and virtually nothing has been done. Instead we have been playing the same old “shell” game over and over (pun intended). All the while we citizens have continued to be part of the consumption problem.
As Oso has pointed out we the people have not pushed congress on limiting the influence of lobbyists and the campaign financing of corporations. In fact the Supreme Court has now made corporations on equal footing with us except they are a hell of a lot richer. They can literally buy elections now. The blame spreading I was speaking of was intended for everyone because there is a gallon or so of that oil in the Gulf that belongs to each of us.
I wrote a post in this column right after the President’s State of the Union Speech called “The Tree.” In it I called for the president to put actions behind his words when he called out the “just say no” Republicans. Did he and the Democrats do it, nope. On the health care bill the wiggle and squirmed, and shuffled until they got a piece of a bill. They are doing much the same with consumer rights bill. The money spoke of in the TARP program for cleaner energy program should have been far more than it was. Given this catastrophe how much could they have saved if they given sufficient tax breaks to homeowners really make their homes energy efficient. Give them enough money to pay for at least half the cost of installing solar energy in their homes. The tax revenue it would generate from the businesses alone with payroll taxes would made it deficit neutral. The point is, no one has the balls to step up and take charge. And if they did the oil, coal, natural gas, and electrical power lobbyists would rip them to shreds. herein lies the problem. We Americans would rather glutton ourselves and them whine when we get an upset stomach.
Sorry for my rant.
Lazersedge
Sound reasoning Lazer, but it was more fun to read “The Blame Game” portion of the rant . . .
At any rate, here’s my problem with BP, and their supporters:
BP-There’s never been a spill like this in the Gulf before.
LazerProdigy-No duh, but thank God that you are correct in that astute observation.
BP-The Gulf floor at that site is a mile below the surface.
LazerProdigy-Uncanny, Captain Obvious! Two incredibly astute observations . . . amazing.
BP-We can’t account for all the diificulties we’re encountering due to the depth at which the site rests.
LazerProdigy-Didn’t seem to be a problem when you drilled that well, now did it?
Admittedly, I’m no expert on oil or offshore drilling, unless you count the numerous times I’ve watched Armageddon (where is Harry Stamper when you need him?), but I have a hard time believing that, up until the top kill method was attempted, BP was actually trying to stop the oil, instead of rerouting it to their bank account.
I think someone should call A.J., Harry thought an awful lot of him . . .
Prodigy, I know there is a point there somewhere but escapes me at the moment. No one in the scenario is blameless but without our insatiable demands for oil and oil based products we might not be in this predicament. BP is acting like a coporation, what did you expect, Mother Teresa.
Mother Therea, no, just someone who acts like they realize that the water down there is much colder than the water on the surface. What they have tried in the last week is what they should have tried within the first week of the explosion. Stop the oil first, pay off goverment regulators second, and then retap the well from a different point third.
It’s really not that hard. 😉
Well ,Prodigy, it see,s that you have the answers. Why not offer your services for hire my man. Personally, though I understand the physics of which speak, do not presume to have the knowledge or skills of those who have specialized education, training, and years of experience in those endeavors. As I said, “i know my limitations.”
My name is not Stamper but it is Harry, if I could stop the BP mess in the gulf I would, and charge you a million bucks to do it.
BigHarry, if you could stop the mess in the Gulf my friend I am quite sure that folks would pay you quite a bit more than a million dollars to do it.
Now this here is a brilliant post. Not like that odd and awkward definition of entropy. You are right lad we are pretty much in the shitter. We are killin our world and by the time me Grandies are grown we will be in the shit for sure. It is sad and you put it just right. I’ll be following you for sure.
Many thanks Centurion. As we elders drift into our end time it is sad to note that the world may be following us in rather order.
you’re right Bill. Lot of blame to go around. Even driving a bug, plenty times I could walk but I don’t.
Oso, it would be so bad if we all had bugs.
Had a bad ignition for a long time so always had to park on a hill. The kids always got a kick out of the car rolling down the steep driveway or a hill till I popped the clutch. Poor man’s Disneyland ride.
I have had several cars like that in the past. Sometimes I miss that fun, but not too much.
Good old days. Had a sister-in-law had to start her truck by crawling underneath to short the starter with a screwdriver. My ex, when I first met her had a pickup truck only had 2nd and 4th gear. Bumpy ride.
Excellent post Bill and the points you make are important.
Thank you Sir Mad Mike.
A sound appreciation of the whole situation Lazer and I agree with what SJ has said. What an opportunity for future of energy (minus carbon) to be laid out in front of us right now. Let’s what genius is made of, because they are out there waiting to be unleashed on big oil, big coal, big carbon energy in general.
Holte, reason is mostly too much to hope for right now, Thanks
I wish our President would say the following:
“Folks, this problem is one that falls squarely on the back of practically everyone in this country in one way or another. We are the blame for the problem whether we want to admit it or not. Until we as a people, and as a nation, truly step up and commit ourselves and resources to getting free of carbon based fuels we will continue to have such disasters. There will be more miners die, more oil well leaks, more oil tanker spills, just more of all of this.”
Very sound reasoning my friend.
-SJ
Thanks SJ. I wish he would too. Unfortunately, we in this country, are a bunch of wimps who always want it to be somebody else’s fault.