Paper Citing a ‘Creator’ Sparks Fury Within Science Community
(NEWSER) – Think a “Divine Creator” belongs in science? Well, a peer-reviewed paper that mentions “the Creator” sparked such an outcry that it’s been retracted with an apology, the Guardian reports.
The paper, about the human hand’s design and dexterity, mentions the “Creator” more than once. “Hand coordination should indicate the mystery of the Creator’s invention,” write co-authors Ming-Jin Liu, Cai-Hua Xiong, Le Xiong, and Xiao-Lin Huang in one instance. They also maintain that the hand’s grasping ability is “the proper design by the Creator to perform a multitude of daily tasks in a comfortable way.”
Published in PLoS ONE, the paper drew such condemning remarks on its comments page and Twitter that the work was retracted. Among the tweets:
- Plos One is now a joke. “….proper design of the Creator” absolute joke of a journalhttps://t.co/AJexYjewoo — James McInerney (@jomcinerney) 2 March 2016
- “Hand coordination should indicate the mystery of the Creator’s invention”–how DID this pass peer review @ PLOSOne?! — Danna Gifford (@dannagifford) 2 March 2016
Others argue that the outcry shows the value of post-publication peer review, while some point out that PLoS ONE isn’t the first scientific journal to publish problematic articles,Nature reports.
A comment apparently posted by a study co-author says they used “Creator” by mistake because they aren’t native English speakers, and will change it to “nature” in a new version.
But in its apology and retraction, PLoS ONE identified deeper concerns “with the scientific rationale, presentation and language” of the paper.
More Stories
What in the World Happened to the Ginger Kitten?
The abrupt sound of multiple barks pierced the stillness of the night. It was an unsettling deviation from their customary...
Warning: Be Careful When Walking Your Dog In Alligator Country
Mike McCoy has read up a bit on alligator attacks and he knew what to do if you find yourself in one—and good thing too.
MadMikesAmerica To Remain Open For Business
We are staying open. MMA may not be as active as it once was, but why close this one, with all those articles still available to read, and maybe more to come?
Fox News Guest: Ghoulish Trump Has Blood On His Hands
Rep. Brad Sherman (D-CA) told Fox News on Sunday that former President Donald Trump is guilty of a “ghoulish” attempt to undermine the economy by downplaying the need for Covid-19 vaccinations.
Disgusting Ted Cruz Forgets History of Conservatives Like Elvis Promoting Vaccines
Recently, the beloved Sesame Street character Big Bird went on television and social media to promote COVID-19 vaccines. For anyone who has been conscious for at least a few years, celebrities—especially ones with larger fanbases amongst the youth of the country—promoting public health initiatives is not surprising. It has been going on forever and ever.
Crazy Louie Gohmert: Climate Action Would Force Us To Brush Our Teeth With Bark
[caption id="attachment_187456" align="aligncenter" width="615"] Getty images[/caption] by Aldous J. Pennyfarthing How the hell did Republican Louie Gohmert of Texas ever become...
Happy religious lobotomy. Apparently religions believe ignorance is bliss.
Religion is the scourge of mankind. I wish I could remember who said that.