Critter talk: Is abortion a sin if you choose it for your cat?

Read Time:3 Minute, 40 Second

This story WILL go down as one of the kookier I can recall. It’s to do with one pregnant cat, two dueling “owners,” and the contentious issue of feline abortion. (Yes, really.)
Though it’s nowhere near the issue it is when it comes to us homo sapiens, feline abortion is fraught, nonetheless, with some degree of discomfiting hand-wringing. Why? I’m not so sure. But this years-old post explores it in more detail than I plan to offer you here. Still, here’s a tiny primer to get you up to speed:

Pregnant cats are commonplace in veterinary practice, especially for veterinarians who engage heavily in TNR (trap-neuter-release) programs. We see, on average, perhaps one pregnant cat for every three brought in under these conditions (cats are scarily adept at the reproduction thing). So to perform an abortion is widely considered a necessary battle in the war against overpopulation.

But not all people agree.

Predictably, perhaps, those who are most affected by the stress of ending a feline fetus’ life fall into one, or both, of two camps:

1) They disavow abortion in any species. A life is a life, human or otherwise, and consciously choosing to end it is morally repugnant to them. Period.

2) Cats must be saved. All cats. A cat fetus is every bit the cat the mother is. The idea of discriminating against a healthy cat when a home might be found for it is to give up on the cat rescue cause altogether.

Both points may seem identical to you but I assure you there are subtle differences here. The first is the view of a consistent “right-to-lifer,” while the latter comes with a lot of practice in what I like to call “extreme cat rescue.” These extreme cat rescuers have a mindset all their own and may think nothing of spending twenty thousand dollars a year on saving four near-dead feral cats, if that’s what it takes to save them.

The woman who brought the pregnant cat early last week was of the latter camp. Though the cat was feral, she thought the kitty was tamable enough to find a home for. But she didn’t want her pregnancy terminated. She sought out simple prenatal care for this cat, with a spay to come at a safe time after the delivery.

Weird, right? Still, I’ve heard kookier stuff from this particular (lovely, really) client.

The trouble was, the obligatory FIV test came back positive. This, along with other evidence of not-quite-optimal health, altered the landscape somewhat. Though we would not be euthanizing the cat on the basis of this diagnosis, we did have some reservations about the kittens, the pregnancy, and the delivery. Should we allow kittens to come into the world with the possibility of an FIV-positive status? (Transmission between mother and fetus is as likely as it is in human AIDS, a distinct but similar-acting virus.) Should we terminate her pregnancy for the sake of her own survival?

For me, the answer was obvious. She should be spayed ASAP. That’s what’s best for the population at large. For the owner, the answer was less obvious. Yet it didn’t take her long to agree that, given this particular set of circumstances, what was best for all was to spay.

Problem solved, right? Not quite.

Enter the woman who had originally found and captured the cat. She was of another mind (camp No. 1, for those keeping track). Must. Not. Kill. No. Matter. What.

Okee-dokee. The problem was, she hadn’t filled out the paperwork and she wasn’t paying the bill, but the calls from her end kept coming anyway. She must have assembled a feline right-to-life club on the spot for all the calls we got from random individuals who were trying to put a stop to the madness and halt the abortion.

Seriously, now. A feral cat whose future was uncertain (she wasn’t even that tame). A set of dueling anti-abortionists of different stripes. It was more than I could handle on a busy day. It was enough to make me want to plug my ears and sing “la la la la la” for the rest of the day.

In the end, we ignored the noise and spayed the cat.

Many thanks to Dr. Patty Khuly and our friends at Fully Vetted/Pet MD

Enhanced by Zemanta

About Post Author

Professor Mike

Professor Mike is a left-leaning, dog loving, political junkie. He has written dozens of articles for Substack, Medium, Simily, and Tribel. Professor Mike has been published at Smerconish.com, among others. He is a strong proponent of the environment, and a passionate protector of animals. In addition he is a fierce anti-Trumper. Take a moment and share his work.
Happy
Happy
0 %
Sad
Sad
0 %
Excited
Excited
0 %
Sleepy
Sleepy
0 %
Angry
Angry
0 %
Surprise
Surprise
0 %
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of

5 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
13 years ago

If females and males were neutered at 6 months or so there would be A) Fewer unwanted kittens and B) fewer cases of FIV and FELV.

The wifey is in the Cats Protection charity over here in England so I sort of know whereof I speak.

Demeur
13 years ago

I wonder if that woman owns a fly swatter?

Jess
13 years ago

Yet, these are probably the same people that consistently say animals have no souls. It makes my head spin the way people like this justify everything, and have no issues doing it. Spay and neuter the pets people. I have two little tame ferals that found their way into my yard couple yrs ago. Took them, got their shots, fixed and what not and they have been taking up space on my side of the bed ever since. I am of the same opinion you are MH, regarding euthanasia.

13 years ago

Nothing is less fun than a dead cat, much less a bunch of really cute dead kittens in a burlap sack with a rock at the bottom of a lake.

Spaying is so important- and I feel this way about people as well- to prevent the suffering of a creature that cannot get its basic needs met.

My sister is of the “extreme” type mentioned above. She will pay ridiculous amounts of money to save an animal that should be euthanized. I am of the opinion that life is good, as long as it is healthy and free of pain, misery and want.

Kitty abortions are, like human ones, a necessary evil.

Reply to  Mother Hen
13 years ago

Agreed, life must be worth living, animals deserve some quality of life, they are not just here for our ego.

Previous post Human Brain – Masterpiece, or, 3 pounds of jelly
Next post Gray wolf back on endangered list…..
5
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x