Study: Gluten Not Causing General Digestive Distress

Read Time:1 Minute, 27 Second

If you’re concerned about the gluten in your diet this Memorial day, you can stop worrying about it, unless you have celiac disease.  It might be a good idea, however, to watch your consumption of wheat and rye.

Wheat contains other possible irritants besides gluten.  (Shutter Stock)
Wheat contains other possible irritants besides gluten.
(Shutter Stock)

From Newser:

Americans and their sensitive bellies bought $10.5 billion worth of gluten-free food products in 2013, but a new study indicates that, with the exception of people with celiac disease, the real gastrointestinal culprit may be something else entirely. Instead of gluten—a protein found in cereal grains like wheat and rye—researchers Peter Gibson and Jessica Biesiekierski are pointing the finger at short-chain carbs known as FODMAPs. The fact that Gibson and Biesiekierski are behind the assertion is notable: Their 2011 research tied gluten to gastrointestinal distress in people without celiac disease, and helped spur the gluten-free trend, reports Real Clear Science.

But lacking an understanding of why gluten caused these reactions, they repeated the experiment in an even more exacting fashion: Participants would be provided with every single meal, which would be free of anything that could cause gastrointestinal distress, from lactose to preservatives. What they found (the results were actually published a year ago) was that the presence or absence of gluten wasn’t a reliable trigger, but FODMAPs—NPRspecifically calls out the FODMAP fructan, which just so happens to be found in wheat—may very well be. Says Biesiekierski of the study’s participants, “Reduction of FODMAPs in their diets uniformly reduced gastrointestinal symptoms.” For those who want to try a low-FODMAP diet, the Daily Mail has a guide to foods that are high and low in them.

About Post Author

Professor Mike

Professor Mike is a left-leaning, dog loving, political junkie. He has written dozens of articles for Substack, Medium, Simily, and Tribel. Professor Mike has been published at Smerconish.com, among others. He is a strong proponent of the environment, and a passionate protector of animals. In addition he is a fierce anti-Trumper. Take a moment and share his work.
Happy
Happy
0 %
Sad
Sad
0 %
Excited
Excited
0 %
Sleepy
Sleepy
0 %
Angry
Angry
0 %
Surprise
Surprise
0 %
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of

5 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
9 years ago

My wife tells me I’m a glutton…I thought for a moment it was just different spelling….clearly not…oops

Is any of this relevent to eating bacon sandwiches? I can’t stop doing that! Ever!

Don’t eat wheat much I don’t think…Cornflakes?

Reply to  Norman Rampart
9 years ago

Norman
You’re good with the bacon, but as soon as you make it into a sandwich, you’re exposing yourself to the “deadly gluten”…unless, of course, you buy the gluten-free bread at 5X the cost of regular bread. 🙂

9 years ago

As we move farther and farther in to the realm of processed foods, we must nurture our “gut biome.” Much of what ails us as “first world problems” has to do with our attempts to sanitize the world to the point that no other organisms can invade our habitat. Anti-microbial has become a curse. Clean is good. Not living with our own sewage is good. Sanitized is unhealthy overkill.

The food demands of the world probably justify the mechanization and mass production of food and the preparation of foods for long shelf lives. As much as I agree with the “eat natural, local, in season … and all that other stuff” movements, the fact is that the whole world simply can’t do that. There’s not enough of “that” stuff to go around, and the evolution of lifestyles has made the daily chore of “fresh” food preparation too demanding….especially on households that have single parents or two working parents. The “natural” et al food movements have become somewhat religious in their fervor, and they can be quite demanding on the time of individuals who are already strapped for time.

So, enough rationalization and excuse-making. But the fact remains that the crap we eat isn’t going anywhere. It won’t go away. It’s likely to increase.

As foods are stripped of many nutrients, and as they are manipulated to give a Twinkie or Oreo a 300 year shelf life, we need to be cognizant of the fact that key elements of natural foods…including those that promote spoilage…may become vital supplements to our diet. To that end, we see lots of “pro-biotics” that pledge to aid digestion. Some actually do a very good job. In desperate cases, believe it or not, there is a highly effective procedure called a fecal transplant. Need I describe???

As I became a crumbling curmudgeon (GET OFF MY LAWN!!), I took up a daily dose of halfway decent Greek yogurt as my recipe for digestive nirvana. None of that “pro-biotic” formula stuff that tasted bad enough that I wouldn’t eat it, mind you. Just some good old Dannon or Chobani (or whatever’s on sale…) Low and behold, it works like a charm. The transformation was borderline miraculous.

So, what’s behind all of this “gluten” nonsense? Credit where credit’s due…some people DO have gluten intolerance. But, well…do I have to tell you? As with any “self-help” phenomenon, from weight-loss crazes to get-rich-quick schemes, the “health food” field is rife with charlatans eager to sell you snake oil. Just because these hucksters are selling nut and twigs and professing to be one with the universe, that doesn’t mean they aren’t P.T. Barnum in disguise. The most vulnerable people are people who are desperate for a cure. They are the ones who’ll give their money to Oral Roberts and let him “lay hands on” them in expectation of a Sunday Morning TV Show “miracle”.

So, if you want to “eat like a cave man” or adopt some similar quasi religion, go right ahead. The plan might even have some merit. But if you’re like most of the rest of the world, and if you want to continue the process of evolution rather than reverting to primordial soup…not as a main course but as a way of existing…don’t fall for every stupid trend that comes along and just try to use your noggin for something other than a place to absorb tweets, posts, instagram photos, and Netflix reruns.

On the other hand, I might launch a website, blog, TV show, studio, healing center, and an institute promoting the healthful benefits of a little yogurt now and then. I could build a Crystal Cathedral for pro-biotics, and I could seek donations from little old ladies who have uncomfortable gas.

Or I just might keep buying a 4-pack at King Soopers now and then and let someone else become the next Oral Roberts of beneficial pro-biotics. I don’t have the inclination to “go to hell” for being a snake oil salesman.

Gluten-free: Bah, humbug! What’s next? Red foods only? Wait…there’s an idea…

Reply to  Professor Mike
9 years ago

“Red foods”…geez, I wish it was “blue foods.” I don’t want to become one of those Tea Party types. 🙂

Previous post Memorial Day Weekend: Remembering Tank Hill
Next post The European Union: Divided Only By The Truth
5
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x